Medicare Advantage Pros and Cons: What Washington Residents Should Weigh

26 min read

The main pros of Medicare Advantage are a yearly cap on what you pay for covered Part A and Part B services (no more than $9,850 in-network in 2027), drug coverage built into most plans, and extra benefits Original Medicare doesn't cover. The main cons are networks and service areas, prior authorization for some care, out-of-pocket costs that can still reach thousands of dollars in a bad year, and, in Washington, no guaranteed way back into a Medigap policy outside the federal trial rights and a few other protected situations.

That's the whole trade in two sentences. Medicare Advantage manages cost and care through a private plan's rules; Original Medicare (often paired with a Medigap policy and a Part D plan) lets you see any provider that takes Medicare but leaves the cost sharing to you or your supplement. Neither is right for everyone. Which way the scale tips depends on your doctors, your prescriptions, where you spend the year, your budget and how you'd handle a year of heavy medical bills.

Rolling green and gold wheat hills of the Palouse in eastern Washington at sunrise, with a red barn and a few trees
The Palouse, eastern Washington. Which providers are in a plan's network can depend on the county you live in. Photo: ky0nch3ng, CC0 1.0

Medicare Advantage pros and cons at a glance

Short answer: every pro of Medicare Advantage comes from the same source as a con. A private plan that controls costs through a network and approval rules can cap your spending and add benefits, but it also decides which providers are in network and when it needs to approve care first.

Two definitions first. Medicare Advantage (Part C) is a Medicare-approved plan from a private company that bundles your Part A (hospital) and Part B (medical) coverage, and usually Part D (drugs), into one plan. Original Medicare is Part A and Part B run by the federal government; people on it often add a separate Part D plan and a Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance) policy, which is private insurance that pays some or most of the cost sharing Original Medicare leaves behind. You can't use both at the same time: it's illegal for anyone to sell you a Medigap policy while you're in Medicare Advantage unless you're switching back to Original Medicare (Medicare & You 2027).

Medicare Advantage: the structural pros and cons
FeatureProCon
Yearly out-of-pocket limitEvery plan has one; in 2027 it can't exceed $9,850 in-network or $14,800 combined in- and out-of-networkThe limit is per plan and can still mean thousands of dollars in a heavy year; Part D drug costs are counted separately
Doctors and hospitalsA network plan organizes your care through a set of contracted providersYou usually need network providers in the plan's service area for non-emergency care; providers can leave the network mid-year
ApprovalsPlans must follow Medicare's coverage rules and decision deadlinesSome services and supplies need prior authorization; HMOs usually need referrals to specialists
Drug coverageMost plans include Part D, so there's one plan instead of twoIf you choose an HMO without drug coverage, you can't add a separate Part D plan
Extra benefitsPlans may add some dental, vision or hearing coverage Original Medicare doesn't haveExtra benefits come with conditions and limits that vary by plan and can change each year
JoiningNo health questions; a pre-existing condition doesn't stop you from joiningLeaving later for Medigap can mean health questions unless a guaranteed-issue right applies
TravelEmergency and urgently needed care is covered anywhere in the U.S.Routine care away from the service area is limited; being away more than 6 months can end your enrollment

Source: CMS, Medicare & You 2027 (pp. 10-12, 65-72, 81); CMS, Final CY 2027 Part C bid review memo (Apr. 22, 2026), Table 3 for the 2027 limits; 42 CFR 422.74; 42 CFR 422.113.

If you're mainly comparing Medicare Advantage against a Medigap policy specifically (monthly premiums, standardized letter plans, Washington's Medigap rules), I wrote a separate explainer on Medicare Advantage vs Medigap in Washington. This article stays on the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage itself, the problems people run into, and the evidence behind them.

What are the advantages of Medicare Advantage?

Short answer: a cap on yearly spending for covered services, one plan that usually includes drug coverage, possible extra benefits, and open enrollment without health questions. Here's each one, with the fine print.

1. A yearly limit on what you pay

This is the biggest structural difference. Original Medicare has no yearly out-of-pocket limit. KFF puts it bluntly: traditional Medicare is the only major form of health insurance without a cap on out-of-pocket spending (KFF, May 2026). Congress actually passed a cap in 1988 and repealed it a year later.

Every Medicare Advantage plan must have a limit on what you pay for covered Part A and Part B services. CMS sets the highest limit a plan may use; each plan can choose a lower one. For 2027 the ceiling is $9,850 for in-network services and $14,800 for in-network and out-of-network services combined (CMS bid review memo, April 22, 2026, Table 3; also reported by KFF).

MA in-network limit, 2027$9,850up $600 from 2026
MA combined limit, 2027$14,800$13,900 in 2026
Part D out-of-pocket cap, 2027$2,400$2,100 in 2026
Original Medicare yearly limitNoneunless you add coverage like Medigap

Source: CMS, Final CY 2027 Part C bid review memo, Table 3 for the 2027 Medicare Advantage limits; KFF (May 28, 2026) for 2026; CMS, CY 2027 Rate Announcement, Table V-2 for Part D.

Why it matters: on Original Medicare alone you usually pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for Part B services after the deductible, with no ceiling. Example: with $40,000 of Medicare-approved outpatient care in a year (think chemotherapy or dialysis), someone on Original Medicare with no supplement and no other coverage would owe the $283 Part B deductible plus 20% of the rest: $8,226.40, using 2026 amounts, before any hospital stay. A Medicare Advantage plan would stop charging for covered in-network services once its limit is reached. A Medigap policy is the other way people limit that exposure, for a monthly premium.

2. One plan, usually with drug coverage

Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D, so you don't need a separate drug plan (Medicare & You 2027, p. 12). The alternative is three moving parts: Original Medicare, a Medigap policy and a stand-alone Part D plan, each with its own card and premium. The Part D out-of-pocket cap applies either way: $2,400 in 2027 under the CMS rate announcement. For drug coverage on its own, see the Washington Part D page.

3. Extra benefits Original Medicare doesn't cover

Original Medicare doesn't cover routine eye exams, most dental care or routine physicals. Medicare Advantage plans must cover everything medically necessary that Original Medicare covers and may add extra benefits, like some vision, hearing and dental services (Medicare & You 2027, p. 12). Federal rules require each plan to disclose those supplemental benefits along with their conditions and limitations (42 CFR 422.111(b)(6)). That last part is the catch: an extra benefit with an annual dollar cap or a narrow list of covered services is worth less than it sounds, so read the plan's Evidence of Coverage, not the summary.

4. Lower monthly cost structure, for some

With Medicare Advantage you still pay the Part B premium ($202.90 a month standard in 2026; CMS hadn't posted the 2027 amount when I wrote this) and you may also pay the plan's premium. Some plans may help pay all or part of the Part B premium (Medicare & You 2027, p. 11). On the other path you pay the Part B premium plus a Medigap premium plus a Part D premium. So the Medicare Advantage structure can move cost out of monthly premiums and into copays you pay when you use care. Whether that costs you less over a year depends on how much care you use.

5. No health questions to join

To join a Medicare Advantage plan you need Part A and Part B, must live in the plan's service area and meet citizenship or lawful-presence rules. You can join even with a pre-existing condition (Medicare & You 2027, p. 68). In Washington that matters because, as covered below, getting into Medigap later is not always as easy.

What are the disadvantages of Medicare Advantage?

Short answer: networks and service areas, prior authorization, mid-year network changes, cost sharing that adds up before the cap, limited routine care away from home, and the difficulty of getting a Medigap policy if you change your mind later.

1. Networks and service areas

With Original Medicare you can see any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that takes Medicare, usually without a referral. In Medicare Advantage you may need to use providers in the plan's network and service area for non-emergency care; some plans cover out-of-network care at a higher cost, and you may need a referral to see a specialist (Medicare & You 2027, p. 11). In an HMO, non-emergency out-of-network care without authorization can leave you paying the full bill.

In Washington this hits hardest where providers are few. If your nearest specialists are across the state line in Portland, Lewiston or Moscow, or a ferry ride away from the San Juans, check that the specific providers you use are in the network before you join, not after.

2. Networks can change during the year

Doctors and hospitals can join or leave a plan's network at any time during the year, but you generally can't change plans mid-year (Medicare & You 2027, p. 66). Federal rules require written notice when a provider leaves: at least 45 days before for a primary care or behavioral health provider, and at least 30 days before for other specialists you see regularly (42 CFR 422.111(e)). When a provider leaves, you usually can't change plans mid-year, though you may qualify for a Special Enrollment Period in some cases; your plan must tell you which enrollment periods apply (Medicare & You 2027, pp. 66, 70). A significant change to a plan's network can create a federal guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap plans if you go back to Original Medicare (Choosing a Medigap Policy, p. 17). Washington's Office of the Insurance Commissioner currently has a notice on its Medigap page for people whose Medicare Advantage plan is changing or leaving their area.

3. Prior authorization and referrals

Prior authorization means the plan must approve a service, supply or drug before it agrees to cover it. In most cases Original Medicare doesn't require it; Medicare Advantage plans may (Medicare & You 2027, p. 12). This is the most-searched "Medicare Advantage problem," so it gets its own section below with the numbers.

4. You still pay until the cap

The out-of-pocket limit is a ceiling, not a typical bill. Copays for hospital days, imaging, outpatient surgery and specialists can add up to thousands of dollars in a year with a serious illness, and the limit resets every January 1.

5. Extra benefits are limited and not guaranteed year to year

Plans set their extra benefits each year. If a dental or vision benefit drives your choice, check what's covered, the yearly maximum, and whether you must use a specific network of dentists or eye doctors. Your plan's Annual Notice of Change lists what changes for next year.

6. Coming back to Medigap isn't always simple

Going from Original Medicare into Medicare Advantage is easy during Open Enrollment. Going back to Original Medicare is easy too. What can be hard is buying a Medigap policy afterward, because outside certain protected situations, insurers can ask health questions. The Washington details are further down.

How often does prior authorization get in the way?

Short answer: Medicare Advantage insurers made about 52.8 million prior authorization decisions in 2024 and denied 7.7% in full or in part. Only 11.5% of denials were appealed, and 80.7% of those appeals were overturned in full or in part (KFF, January 2026).

MA prior authorization decisions, 202452.8M1.7 per enrollee
Denied in full or in part7.7%about 4.1 million
Denials that were appealed11.5%
Appeals overturned (fully or partly)80.7%

Source: KFF, Medicare Advantage insurers made nearly 53 million prior authorization determinations in 2024 (Jan. 28, 2026), analysis of CMS data.

Prior authorization requests per Medicare Advantage enrollee Average number of prior authorization determinations per enrollee, 2019-2024

Source: KFF (Jan. 28, 2026), analysis of CMS Medicare Advantage data

Show the numbers
Requests per enrollee
20191.7
20201.4
20211.5
20221.7
20231.8
20241.7

The appeal number is the one I'd remember. Four out of five appealed denials were reversed at least in part, yet almost nine out of ten denials were never appealed. If a plan denies something your doctor says you need, appeal. The Medicare appeal process post walks through the levels and deadlines.

Federal investigators have looked at this too. In a 2022 report, the HHS Office of Inspector General reviewed a sample of Medicare Advantage prior authorization denials from one week in June 2019 and found that 13% of them met Medicare coverage rules, meaning they likely would have been approved under Original Medicare; 18% of sampled payment denials also met Medicare and plan billing rules (OIG, OEI-09-18-00260). The OIG pointed to plans using clinical criteria not found in Medicare coverage rules and to requests denied for missing documentation when the records were already enough.

What the rules now require of plans

CMS has tightened the rules since then. A few that protect you directly:

  • Same coverage criteria as Original Medicare. Plans must follow Medicare's national coverage determinations and coverage rules, such as the inpatient admission criteria (42 CFR 422.101(b)).
  • Limited purpose. Prior authorization may only be used to confirm a diagnosis or medical criteria and to make sure a service is medically necessary. Once approved, the plan can't later deny it for lack of medical necessity except for good cause or fraud (42 CFR 422.138).
  • Deadlines. Since January 1, 2026, standard decisions on items and services that need prior authorization are due within 7 calendar days (extendable up to 14 days in certain cases), and expedited decisions within 72 hours (42 CFR 422.568, 42 CFR 422.572). Starting in 2027, your plan may process requests electronically and show decisions in your patient portal (Medicare & You 2027, p. 69).
  • Emergencies. Plans must pay for emergency and urgently needed care whether you're in or out of network and whether or not you had prior authorization (42 CFR 422.113).
  • Switching mid-treatment. If you join a plan in the middle of a course of treatment, the plan must give you at least a 90-day transition period without disrupting it or requiring reauthorization, even with an out-of-network provider (42 CFR 422.112(b)(8)).

Original Medicare in Washington now has some prior authorization too

Prior authorization is no longer purely a Medicare Advantage issue here. CMS's WISeR model adds prior authorization (or a review before payment) in Original Medicare for a selected set of items and services, such as skin and tissue substitutes, electrical nerve stimulator implants and knee arthroscopy for knee osteoarthritis. Washington is one of six states in the model, along with Arizona, New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma and Texas. It excludes emergency services and inpatient-only services, and it doesn't apply to Medicare Advantage (CMS, WISeR Model). It runs for six performance years, from January 1, 2026 to December 31, 2031 (CMS). The list is short, so for most care Original Medicare still doesn't require approval, but "never any prior authorization" is no longer quite accurate in Washington. KFF counted about 2 prior authorization reviews per 100 Original Medicare beneficiaries in fiscal 2024, against 1.7 per enrollee in Medicare Advantage (KFF).

What does the out-of-pocket limit really protect?

Short answer: it caps what you pay for covered Part A and Part B services in a calendar year, using the plan's own limit, which can't be higher than CMS's ceiling. It doesn't include your premiums or your Part D drug costs, and in an HMO it doesn't cover out-of-network care you weren't authorized to get.

Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket ceilings set by CMS Highest limit a plan may set for covered Part A and B services; plans may set lower limits
  • In-network
  • In- and out-of-network combined

Source: KFF (May 28, 2026) for 2026; CMS, Final CY 2027 Part C bid review memo (Apr. 22, 2026), Table 3 for 2027

Show the numbers
In-networkIn- and out-of-network combined
2026$9,250$13,900
2027$9,850$14,800

Example (2027 ceilings, hypothetical): someone in a plan that uses the maximum allowed in-network limit has a year with a hospital stay, surgery and months of follow-up, all in network. The most they'd pay for covered medical services is $9,850. If their prescriptions are expensive too, Part D cost sharing stops at $2,400. That's a worst case of $12,250 for the year, plus any plan premium and the Part B premium. Plans can set lower limits; the plan's Evidence of Coverage shows its actual number.

Compare that with the other path. Original Medicare with a Medigap policy can bring covered medical costs close to zero (depending on the letter plan), but you pay the Medigap premium every month whether you use care or not. People who choose Medicare Advantage are, in effect, accepting the risk of copays up to the limit in exchange for not paying a supplement premium. The Medicare Advantage vs Medigap post works through a dollar example on both sides.

Is Medicare Advantage a problem for travel or snowbirds?

Short answer: it can be. Medicare Advantage plans cover emergency and urgently needed care anywhere in the U.S., but routine care is generally tied to the plan's local service area, and if you're gone more than 6 months the plan generally must disenroll you.

Travelers walking along a moving walkway in a bright, glass-walled airport concourse
Routine care in another state works differently under Medicare Advantage than under Original Medicare. Photo: Negative Space, CC0 1.0

Under federal rules, if you haven't moved but you've been out of the plan's service area for more than 6 months, the plan must disenroll you. The exception: a plan that offers a visitor or traveler benefit may let you stay enrolled longer, up to 12 months under the current rule (42 CFR 422.74(d)(4)). Not every plan offers that benefit, so ask before you rely on it.

Original Medicare works with any provider in the U.S. that accepts Medicare, which is why people who spend winters in Arizona or split time with family back east often look hard at it. Outside the U.S., neither path covers much: Original Medicare and most Medicare Advantage plans generally don't cover care abroad, though some plans offer an emergency benefit (Medicare & You 2027, p. 12). Medigap Plans C, D, F, G, M and N cover 80% of emergency care abroad during the first 60 days of a trip after a $250 deductible, up to $50,000 in a lifetime (CMS, Choosing a Medigap Policy, plan chart; WAC 284-66-064).

A permanent move is different from travel. If you move out of your plan's service area, you get a Special Enrollment Period that starts when you move and lasts 2 full months afterward, and if you don't pick a new plan, you'll be enrolled in Original Medicare when the old plan drops you (Medicare.gov).

Can I switch back to Medigap in Washington?

Short answer: you can always return to Original Medicare during the right enrollment period, but buying a Medigap policy afterward is guaranteed only in certain federal situations, such as the 12-month trial rights. Washington's own any-time switching rule, RCW 48.66.045, covers moving from one Medigap policy to another; it doesn't expressly cover someone coming from Medicare Advantage.

Guaranteed issue means an insurer must sell you a Medigap policy without health questions and can't charge more because of your health. Here's when you can leave Medicare Advantage, and when the Medigap side is protected.

Leaving Medicare Advantage: enrollment windows and federal Medigap rights
Window or rightWhenWhat you can do
Open EnrollmentOct 15 - Dec 7 each yearSwitch from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare (or the reverse); change plans; coverage starts Jan 1
Medicare Advantage Open EnrollmentJan 1 - Mar 31If you're in Medicare Advantage: one switch to another plan or back to Original Medicare plus a Part D plan
Special Enrollment PeriodsAfter certain eventsExamples: moving out of the service area (2 full months), moving out of an institution such as a nursing home (2 full months), losing Medicaid (3 full months)
Federal trial right (new at 65)Within the first year in Medicare AdvantageJoined Medicare Advantage when first eligible at 65: any Medigap policy sold in your state, guaranteed
Federal trial right (dropped Medigap)Within the first year, first time in Medicare AdvantageYour old Medigap policy back if still sold; otherwise Plan A, B, D or G (C or F if eligible before 2020)
Plan leaves or network changes60 days before to 63 days after coverage endsIf the plan leaves Medicare or your area, you move, or the network significantly changes: Plan A, B, D or G guaranteed (C or F if eligible before 2020)

Source: CMS, Medicare & You 2027 (p. 84); Medicare.gov, Special Enrollment Periods; CMS, Choosing a Medigap Policy (pp. 17-18).

Outside those situations, here's what Washington law says. RCW 48.66.045 requires Medigap insurers to issue Plans B, D, G, high-deductible G, K, L, M or N without evidence of insurability when the new policy replaces another Medicare supplement policy "or other more comprehensive coverage" (people eligible for Medicare before 2020 can also use C, F and high-deductible F; Plan A can replace Plan A). Washington's Office of the Insurance Commissioner explains it in plain terms: if you have Medigap Plan B through N you can switch at any time to another B through N with no health screening, but if you're switching from some other type of health insurance plan, rules can vary and insurers may require a written health screening questionnaire (WA OIC). If you're unsure whether a screening applies to you, the OIC's consumer hotline at 800-562-6900 can connect you with a health compliance analyst.

The Legislature has considered changing this. House Bill 1603 would require guaranteed issue of Medigap for someone who voluntarily leaves Medicare Advantage, and HB 1754 would create a guaranteed-issue open enrollment period. Neither bill got out of the House Health Care & Wellness Committee before the 2026 session ended, and neither became law.

Two practical points. If you're new to Medicare and unsure, the first-year trial right is your safety net, so mark the date. And if you already have Medigap and are thinking about trying Medicare Advantage, don't cancel the Medigap policy until the new coverage is confirmed. Washington isn't a "birthday rule" state, and there's no annual Medigap window that reopens for everyone. More on the Medigap side in Medicare Supplement plans in Washington and on the Washington Medicare Supplement page.

How many people in Washington choose Medicare Advantage?

Short answer: about 54% of eligible Washington Medicare beneficiaries (those with both Part A and Part B) were in a Medicare Advantage plan in March 2026, close to the national 55%, according to KFF's analysis of CMS data (KFF). Nationally that share has nearly tripled since 2007.

Share of eligible Medicare beneficiaries in Medicare Advantage, U.S. Percent of beneficiaries with Part A and Part B, March of each year, 2007-2026

Source: KFF, Medicare Advantage in 2026: Enrollment Update and Key Trends (Figure 1 data)

Show the numbers
Medicare Advantage share
200719.0%
200822.0%
200924.0%
201025.0%
201126.0%
201227.0%
201329.0%
201431.0%
201532.0%
201633.0%
201735.0%
201837.0%
201939.0%
202042.0%
202146.0%
202248.0%
202351.0%
202454.0%
202554.0%
202655.0%

Inside Washington the split is anything but even. Medicare Advantage is the majority choice in nine Washington counties, led by Clark, Cowlitz, Snohomish and Spokane, and a small minority in much of the rural east and on the Olympic Peninsula.

Medicare Advantage share by Washington county, March 2026 The nine majority-Medicare Advantage counties and the six lowest of Washington's 39 counties; percent of beneficiaries with Part A and Part B
Clark County74.2%Cowlitz County71.0%Snohomish County66.5%Spokane County62.0%King County60.0%Lewis County60.0%Pierce County57.2%Thurston County56.9%Whatcom County50.4%Jefferson County16.7%Columbia County16.3%San Juan County15.8%Lincoln County14.8%Klickitat County8.5%Garfield County3.1%

Source: KFF county appendix data from Medicare Advantage in 2026

Show the numbers
CountyShare in Medicare Advantage
Clark County74.2%
Cowlitz County71.0%
Snohomish County66.5%
Spokane County62.0%
King County60.0%
Lewis County60.0%
Pierce County57.2%
Thurston County56.9%
Whatcom County50.4%
Jefferson County16.7%
Columbia County16.3%
San Juan County15.8%
Lincoln County14.8%
Klickitat County8.5%
Garfield County3.1%

Don't read this chart as a recommendation in either direction. A high share might reflect strong local networks, employer retiree plans (16% of Medicare Advantage enrollees nationally are in employer or union group plans, per KFF) or simply habit. A low share can mean fewer plan choices or fewer contracted providers nearby. What it does tell you: in counties like Klickitat, Garfield or San Juan, check provider networks especially carefully, because your nearest hospital or specialist may be in another county or state.

Which situations tip the balance?

Short answer: the same plan structure can be a good fit for one person and a poor fit for their neighbor. These are the situations that most often change the math, and what to check for each. None of them decide it alone.

Situations that change the Medicare Advantage decision
If this describes youWhy it mattersWhat to check
You see specific specialists or a particular hospitalNetwork plans may not include them, and networks can change mid-yearLook up each provider in the plan's directory and in Plan Finder; ask the office which plans it contracts with
You spend months away from WashingtonRoutine care is tied to the service area; more than 6 months away can end enrollmentAsk whether the plan has a visitor/traveler benefit; compare with Original Medicare's nationwide acceptance
You want predictable monthly costsMedigap puts more of the cost into a monthly premium; Medicare Advantage relies more on copays up to its yearly limitAdd up premiums plus the plan's out-of-pocket limit for a bad year, both ways
You're new to Medicare at 65You have a 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment and a first-year trial rightNote your Part B start date and the 12-month trial-right date
You've had Medicare for years and have health conditionsBuying Medigap later may involve health questions in WashingtonBefore leaving any Medigap policy, confirm what you could get back
Dental, vision or hearing coverage matters a lotExtra benefits vary and have limitsRead the Evidence of Coverage for yearly maximums and networks
You have Apple Health (Medicaid) or Extra HelpDifferent plan types and enrollment periods may applyAsk SHIBA or the Health Care Authority about options for dual-eligible people

Source: CMS, Medicare & You 2027; 42 CFR 422.74; CMS, Choosing a Medigap Policy; WA OIC; Medicare.gov, Special Enrollment Periods.

How to compare for yourself, step by step

Short answer: list your providers and drugs, enter them in the Medicare.gov Plan Finder, compare a bad year as well as a normal one, and get a second look from SHIBA or a licensed agent before December 7.

  1. Write down your doctors, hospitals and pharmacies. Include specialists you see only once a year.
  2. List every prescription with dose and how often you take it.
  3. Open the Medicare.gov Plan Finder. Enter your ZIP code, drugs and pharmacies; it lets you compare Original Medicare with Part D against Medicare Advantage for your ZIP code, and lets you check providers.
  4. Compare two years, not one. A healthy year (premiums plus a few copays) and a bad year (premiums plus the plan's out-of-pocket limit plus the Part D cap).
  5. Read the documents. The Evidence of Coverage shows prior authorization rules, extra-benefit limits and the plan's actual out-of-pocket limit. If you're already in a plan, read the Annual Notice of Change it mailed for 2027.
  6. Check your way back. If you'd leave Medigap to try Medicare Advantage, know whether you'd have a trial right.
  7. Get a second opinion. SHIBA, the Office of the Insurance Commissioner's free, unbiased Medicare counseling program, takes calls at 800-562-6900 (more in my post on how SHIBA works). You can also call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227; TTY 1-877-486-2048).

Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage ends December 7, 2026; the 2027 Open Enrollment guide covers what you can change and when it takes effect. For an overview of how Medicare works in this state, see the Washington Medicare page. If you'd like to talk it through, you can reach Maru Insurance using the contact details below.

FAQ

What are the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage?

The main pros are a yearly out-of-pocket limit on covered Part A and B services (no more than $9,850 in-network in 2027), drug coverage in most plans, possible extra benefits like some dental, vision and hearing, and no health questions to join. The main cons are provider networks and service areas, prior authorization for some services, networks that can change mid-year, and limited options to buy Medigap later if you change your mind.

What are the biggest problems with Medicare Advantage?

The most common complaints involve networks and prior authorization. In 2024, Medicare Advantage insurers denied 7.7% of prior authorization requests in full or in part; only 11.5% of denials were appealed, and 80.7% of appeals were overturned at least in part, according to KFF.

What is the Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum for 2027?

Plans may set their own limit, but it can't be higher than $9,850 for in-network services or $14,800 for in-network and out-of-network services combined. In 2026 the ceilings are $9,250 and $13,900. Part D drug costs have a separate cap of $2,400 in 2027.

Can I switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare and Medigap in Washington?

You can return to Original Medicare during Open Enrollment (October 15 to December 7), the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31) or a Special Enrollment Period. Buying Medigap is a separate step: it's guaranteed in federal situations like the first-year trial rights, but otherwise Washington insurers may require a written health screening. RCW 48.66.045 requires issue without health questions when the new Medigap policy replaces another Medigap policy or "other more comprehensive coverage"; the OIC says that when you switch from another type of plan, rules can vary and insurers may require a health screening.

Does Medicare Advantage work if I travel or spend winters out of state?

Emergency and urgently needed care is covered anywhere in the U.S., but routine care is generally tied to the plan's service area. If you're away more than 6 months, the plan generally must disenroll you, unless it offers a visitor or traveler benefit, which can extend that to 12 months.

Does Original Medicare ever require prior authorization?

Rarely, but it's no longer never. CMS's WISeR model adds prior authorization or pre-payment review in Original Medicare for a short list of services, such as skin and tissue substitutes, electrical nerve stimulator implants and knee arthroscopy for knee osteoarthritis, and Washington is one of the six states in the model. It doesn't apply to emergency services or to Medicare Advantage.

How many people in Washington have Medicare Advantage?

About 54% of eligible Washington Medicare beneficiaries were in a Medicare Advantage plan in March 2026, compared with 55% nationally, according to KFF. By county it ranges from about 3% in Garfield County to 74% in Clark County.

Where can I get unbiased help comparing Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare?

SHIBA, the Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner's free Medicare counseling program, at 800-562-6900; 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227); and the Medicare.gov Plan Finder, which lets you enter your drugs and providers.

Your own plan or policy documents and federal and Washington law control what's covered. Confirm your situation with a licensed agent, SHIBA, the Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner or 1-800-MEDICARE, and for legal questions, an attorney.

Sources

  1. CMS: Medicare & You 2027 handbook
  2. CMS: Choosing a Medigap Policy (guide to health insurance for people with Medicare)
  3. Medicare.gov: Special Enrollment Periods
  4. Medicare.gov Plan Finder
  5. CMS: 2026 Medicare Parts A & B premiums and deductibles
  6. CMS: Announcement of CY 2027 Medicare Advantage capitation rates and Part C and D payment policies (Apr. 6, 2026)
  7. CMS Innovation Center: WISeR (Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction) Model
  8. CMS HPMS memo: Final Contract Year 2027 Standards for Part C Benefits, Bid Review and Evaluation (Apr. 22, 2026)
  9. KFF: Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket limits, variation and trends (May 28, 2026)
  10. KFF: Medicare open enrollment FAQ on comparing Medicare Advantage options (2027 limits)
  11. KFF: Medicare Advantage insurers made nearly 53 million prior authorization determinations in 2024 (Jan. 28, 2026)
  12. KFF: Medicare Advantage in 2026, enrollment update and key trends
  13. KFF: Figure 1 data, Medicare Advantage enrollment share 2007-2026
  14. KFF: state appendix data, Medicare Advantage penetration, March 2026
  15. KFF: county appendix data, Medicare Advantage penetration, March 2026
  16. HHS OIG: Some Medicare Advantage organization denials of prior authorization requests raise concerns (OEI-09-18-00260, Apr. 2022)
  17. 42 CFR 422.74, disenrollment by the MA organization
  18. 42 CFR 422.101, requirements relating to basic benefits
  19. 42 CFR 422.111, disclosure requirements
  20. 42 CFR 422.112, access to services
  21. 42 CFR 422.113, emergency and urgently needed services
  22. 42 CFR 422.138, prior authorization
  23. 42 CFR 422.568, standard organization determinations
  24. 42 CFR 422.572, expedited organization determinations
  25. RCW 48.66.045, mandated coverage for replacement policies
  26. WAC 284-66-064, Medigap benefit standards
  27. Washington Legislature: HB 1603 (2025-26)
  28. Washington Legislature: HB 1754 (2025-26)
  29. WA OIC: Medigap (Medicare Supplement) plan coverage and costs
  30. WA OIC: Free Medicare help from SHIBA

Vadim Marusin

Vadim Marusin is a licensed independent insurance agent and the owner of Maru Insurance, serving Washington (WA License WAOIC #1365574) and Florida (FL License #G363233), NPN 22261820.

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal, tax or insurance advice. Coverage depends on the actual policy, its terms, conditions and exclusions, and state law. Maru Insurance · WA License (WAOIC) #1365574 · FL License #G363233 · NPN 22261820.